Have we seen the top for yields?


The economic data through April has been good news, but the drop in global yields suggests the opposite. We provide our thoughts.


Thomas Garretson, CFA
Senior Portfolio Strategist
Fixed Income Strategies
Portfolio Advisory Group – U.S.

After a blistering start to the year, Treasury yields have retreated from one-year highs to one-month lows even as the incoming economic data had a blistering start to April.

First there was the ISM Manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) on Apr. 1 that showed the largest uptick in activity since 1983. That was then followed by the jobs report that showed nearly one million jobs added in March. Not to be outdone, the Service Sector PMI, on Apr. 5, showed activity running at the strongest level on record, dating back to 1997. Then this week we saw the headline Consumer Price Index pop to 2.6 percent year over year, and though largely fueled by weak prices this time last year, this is another sign that continues to point toward building inflationary pressures, in our opinion. Finally, stimulus-fueled retail sales data this week was off the charts, up nearly 10 percent month over month.

So, since reaching 1.75 percent at the end of March, the benchmark U.S. 10-year Treasury yield has slipped back to nearly 1.50 percent, seemingly putting the “rising rate” narrative firmly on the back burner, at least for the time being.

So what gives?

Surveying the landscape of traders and analysts this week looking for explanations, we think one thing is clear—no one really has any.

The easiest explanation might just be that after the torrid start to the year, yields were inevitably due for a period of consolidation. Foreign demand for U.S. bonds has also picked up notably in recent months, while the start of earnings season typically brings a glut of new corporate bond issuance—which tends to drive demand for Treasuries and hedging. The Fed continues to push back against the idea that rate hikes are anywhere on the horizon, with Fed Chair Jerome Powell stating this week that the conditions necessary for liftoff are highly unlikely before the end of 2022, let alone this year.

On top of Powell pushing back against the market’s recent expectations regarding rate hikes, he also continues to signal that near-term inflationary pressures will only be transitory, and that downside risks over the long term remain. As the chart shows, the spike in the Consumer Price Index this week to 2.6 percent is expected by RBC Economics to crescendo near 3.6 percent this quarter before falling sharply back to more stable levels.

Jump in consumer prices still seen as temporary
Line graph of Jump in consumer prices still seen as temporary

The line chart shows the recent trend in the Consumer Price Index year-over-year change since 2018 and the expected jump to 3.6% in the second quarter this year, which is then expected to slow to re-normal levels around the Fed’s 2% target through 2022.

Consumer Price Index (y/y)
RBC forecast

Fed’s 2% target

Source – RBC Wealth Management, RBC Economics, Bloomberg; data as of 4/14/21

But maybe it just comes down to the classic explanation that markets—being forward-looking as they are—had already priced in a lot, if not all, of the good news and stimulus that we have seen of late, with traders now awaiting any catalyst that might be cause to take yields to the next leg higher.

Not all rising rate environments are the same

While global yields are moving lower this week, the fear around rising rates continues to be front of mind for investors and portfolios, with this recent pullback only likely to amplify the issue should yields resume their march higher.

And higher yields remain the base case, in our view. This month, RBC Economics upgraded its economic and rate forecasts, as did most analysts, with our colleagues now seeing the 10-year Treasury yield rising to 2.05 percent, up from 1.85 percent previously, by this time next year.

But what does this actually mean for bond prices and portfolio performance? With all of the moving parts in fixed income securities, things can get pretty murky, pretty quickly. At a high level, higher yields mean lower bond prices, but by how much, and how much coupon income is needed to offset declines in bond prices?

The table shows how bonds are likely to perform over the next year based on RBC Economics forecasts for the 2-year, 10-year, and 30-year Treasury yields. But higher Treasury yields don’t necessarily translate exactly to other sectors. Muni bond yields are likely to remain less sensitive to movements in Treasury yields as investor demand is likely to remain elevated amid the risk of higher tax rates. Corporate bond yields will also rise in sympathy with Treasury yields, but to a lesser extent.

Scenario analysis: What impact does “rising rates” have on bond prices and portfolio performance?
Security type Maturity Coupon Current yield Current price Q2 2022 forecast yield Q2 2022 forecast price Yield change Price change Coupon income One-year total return
Treasuries 2Y 0.1% 0.16% $999 0.90% $994 0.74% -$5 $1 -0.4%
10Y 1.1% 1.61% $962 2.05% $931 0.44% -$31 $11 -2.1%
30Y 1.9% 2.30% $926 2.60% $861 0.30% -$65 $19 -5.0%
Investment-grade corporates 2Y 0.8% 0.61% $1,004 1.30% $993 0.69% -$11 $8 -0.3%
10Y 2.6% 2.46% $1,011 2.85% $984 0.39% -$27 $26 -0.1%
30Y 3.6% 3.41% $1,028 3.60% $1,001 0.19% -$27 $36 0.8%
Municipals 2Y 5.0% 0.08% $1,121 0.45% $1,071 0.37% -$50 $50 0.0%
10Y 4.0% 0.94% $1,177 1.19% $1,139 0.25% -$38 $40 0.2%
30Y 4.0% 1.87% $1,178 2.12% $1,145 0.25% -$33 $40 0.6%

Source – RBC Wealth Management, RBC Economics; data through 4/14/21

And, for the most part, the damage is actually minimal. Outside of Treasuries, the decline in bond prices due to higher market yields is more than offset by the interest earned from coupons over that one-year period. For example, if the 10-year Treasury yield rises to 2.05 percent, the price falls by $31, which isn’t offset by the $11 in coupons. A comparable 10-year corporate would see its price fall by $27, nearly fully covered by $26 in coupons, and it’s a similar story for municipals. And longer-dated securities may actually offer investors attractive value around current levels.

So the outlook may not be as bleak as feared by many fixed income investors, particularly as we believe any further rise in yields is likely to be more gradual than we have seen in recent months.

In Quebec, financial planning services are provided by RBC Wealth Management Financial Services Inc. which is licensed as a financial services firm in that province. In the rest of Canada, financial planning services are available through RBC Dominion Securities Inc.

Thomas Garretson, CFA

Senior Portfolio Strategist
Fixed Income Strategies
Portfolio Advisory Group – U.S.

Let’s connect

We want to talk about your financial future.

Related articles

Investing in Canada’s tech ecosystem

Analysis 3 minute read
- Investing in Canada’s tech ecosystem

Four things you need to know about the future of work

Analysis 4 minute read
- Four things you need to know about the future of work

Energy matters: Canada’s options for the 2020s

Analysis 3 minute read
- Energy matters: Canada’s options for the 2020s