Redder: Updating our recession scorecard


Midway through 2024, changes in our U.S. Recession Scorecard signal rising economic risks for equity investors in the second half of the year.


June 13, 2024

Jim Allworth
Investment Strategist
RBC Dominion Securities

Just two years ago, our Recession Scorecard was flashing nothing but green lights for the U.S. economy. That unequivocally unanimous rating began to deteriorate in the summer of 2022. First, in July 2022, the Treasury yield curve inverted when the 1-year Treasury yield rose above the 10-year yield, signaling that credit conditions were tightening in a serious way. Every recession in more than 100 years has been preceded by such a yield shift.

A couple of months later another of our seven indicators – the Conference Board’s Leading Economic Index – went red by falling below where it had been a year earlier. This has occurred before the onset of every U.S. recession since the late 1950s, or for as long as this indicator has been around. In the months that followed, three more Scorecard indicators shifted out of the positive green zone and into cautionary yellow territory.

Now, a third Scorecard indicator has been rerated to the recessionary red column: as of Q1, the growth rate of U.S. nominal GDP has fallen below the federal funds rate. Such a crossing point has occurred either before or just after the start of every recession going back to the 1950s.

U.S. Recession Scorecard

U.S. Recession Scorecard

* Potential change to Recessionary status pending.

Source – RBC Wealth Management

Indicator Status
Yield curve (10-year to 1-year Treasuries) Recessionary
Unemployment claims Neutral/Cautionary
Unemployment rate Expansionary; potential change to Recessionary pending
Conference Board Leading Economic Index Recessionary
Non-financial corporate cash flows Expansionary
ISM New Orders minus Inventories Neutral/Cautionary
Fed funds rate vs. nominal GDP growth Recessionary

The notional economic linkage for this indicator is with categories of spending – primarily residential construction, business capital investment, and consumer spending on durables – for which the cost of borrowing is an important determinant. While not the largest component of GDP, at about 25 percent, spending on fixed assets and durables is highly cyclical. It is often a major contributing factor to recessions, usually going into outright decline under pressure from high interest rates, restricted availability of credit, and falling consumer demand.

One other Scorecard indicator – the unemployment rate – could be poised to flip into the red column, perhaps as early as next month. U.S. unemployment has risen in three of the past four months and now sits at 4.0 percent, its highest reading in almost two-and-a-half years. That has been enough to turn our trend-smoothing line for this data series upward for the first time since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.

As things stand, three of the seven indicators are rated “Recessionary,” and two are set at “Cautionary,” while two remain at “Expansionary” green. If the unemployment rate shifts to red next month, the count will become 4, 2, and 1. There is no score that makes a recession unquestionably inevitable. But even at today’s levels, the Scorecard portrays a decidedly different risk profile for the U.S. economy than the wall of green that prevailed in the decade following the global financial crisis and was restored within a few months of the short-lived pandemic-induced plunge.

U.S. recessions and equity bear markets in the developed world’s stock markets tend to go hand in hand. In our view, a redder tilt in our Scorecard should keep investors alert to a riskier, more challenging environment for equities that might arrive in the coming quarters.

Beware U.S. recessions

Equity bear markets typically accompany economic contractions

Performance of four major equity indexes since December 1959

The line chart shows the performance of four major equity indexes since December 1959: the S&P 500, S&P/TSX, MSCI Europe (since 1987), and FTSE All-Share. Performance is shown on a logarithmic scale, indexed to December 1959 = 100. Periods of U.S. economic recession are highlighted. All four indexes have followed similar generally rising paths, with periods of declining performance corresponding to recessions.

  • S&P 500
  • S&P/TSX
  • MSCI Europe
  • FTSE All‑Share

Shaded areas represent U.S. recessions.

Source – Standard & Poor’s, Toronto Stock Exchange, FactSet; quarterly data through 3/31/24, shown on a logarithmic scale, indexed to December 1959 = 100

The material herein is for informational purposes only and is not directed at, nor intended for distribution to or use by, any person or entity in any country where such distribution or use would be contrary to law or regulation or which would subject Royal Bank of Canada or its subsidiaries or constituent business units (including RBC Wealth Management) to any licensing or registration requirement within such country.

This is not intended to be either a specific offer by any Royal Bank of Canada entity to sell or provide, or a specific invitation to apply for, any particular financial account, product or service. Royal Bank of Canada does not offer accounts, products or services in jurisdictions where it is not permitted to do so, and therefore the RBC Wealth Management business is not available in all countries or markets.

The information contained herein is general in nature and is not intended, and should not be construed, as professional advice or opinion provided to the user, nor as a recommendation of any particular approach. Nothing in this material constitutes legal, accounting or tax advice and you are advised to seek independent legal, tax and accounting advice prior to acting upon anything contained in this material. Interest rates, market conditions, tax and legal rules and other important factors which will be pertinent to your circumstances are subject to change. This material does not purport to be a complete statement of the approaches or steps that may be appropriate for the user, does not take into account the user’s specific investment objectives or risk tolerance and is not intended to be an invitation to effect a securities transaction or to otherwise participate in any investment service.

To the full extent permitted by law neither RBC Wealth Management nor any of its affiliates, nor any other person, accepts any liability whatsoever for any direct or consequential loss arising from any use of this document or the information contained herein. No matter contained in this material may be reproduced or copied by any means without the prior consent of RBC Wealth Management. RBC Wealth Management is the global brand name to describe the wealth management business of the Royal Bank of Canada and its affiliates and branches, including, RBC Investment Services (Asia) Limited, Royal Bank of Canada, Hong Kong Branch, and the Royal Bank of Canada, Singapore Branch. Additional information available upon request.

Royal Bank of Canada is duly established under the Bank Act (Canada), which provides limited liability for shareholders.

® Registered trademark of Royal Bank of Canada. Used under license. RBC Wealth Management is a registered trademark of Royal Bank of Canada. Used under license. Copyright © Royal Bank of Canada 2024. All rights reserved.

Jim Allworth

Investment Strategist
RBC Dominion Securities

Let’s connect

We want to talk about your financial future.

Related articles

High expectations for the U.S. equity market

Analysis 9 minute read
- High expectations for the U.S. equity market

Global Insight 2024 Outlook: Investing for a new reality

Analysis 9 minute read
- Global Insight 2024 Outlook: Investing for a new reality

A durable equity rally faces strengthening headwinds

Analysis 11 minute read
- A durable equity rally faces strengthening headwinds