Recession scorecard update: Stop and start

Analysis
Insights

There have been no recent scorecard rating changes. However, two of the seven indicators have failed to move in the anticipated direction over the past month.

Share

October 10, 2024

Jim Allworth
Investment Strategist
RBC Dominion Securities

Unemployment rate

The unemployment rate fell for the second straight month. That decline has not altered its “red” status. The monthly rate has been above the smoothed trend for eight consecutive months, and that smoothed trend continues to rise. However, the gap between the two has narrowed, and we think two more months of a falling unemployment rate would, at the very least, muddy the picture.

U.S. monthly unemployment running above trend

U.S. unemployment rate and 3-month smoothed trend

U.S. unemployment rate and 3-month smoothed trend

The line chart shows the U.S. unemployment rate and its 3-month smoothed trend from 1950 through September 2024. Both the rate and the trend line have been rising since mid-2023, and the rate has been above the trend for eight months. In September, the unemployment rate was 4.1% and the smoothed trend value was 4.0%.

  • U.S. unemployment rate
  • Unemployment rate (smoothed)
  • U.S. recessions

Source – RBC Wealth Management, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED); data through 9/30/24

The unemployment rate is important to the “recession/no recession” discussion for at least two reasons: because of its perfect track record of signaling the imminent onset of recession since it was first published in 1948, and because it factors mightily into Fed thinking about whether to and by how much to cut rates.

Fed Chair Jerome Powell, in the press conference following the Federal Open Market Committee’s September meeting, noted that the labour market had cooled and that the Fed would not welcome any additional weakness on the employment front. Many observers believed the Fed’s September rate cut was larger than normal because of the surge in the reported July unemployment rate to 4.3 percent.

Several factors argue in favour of the unemployment rate resuming its climb in the coming months:

  • Temporary employment continued to fall even in September’s blowout payroll gains. Employers typically reduce temp jobs before they lay off permanent employees.
  • The multi-quarter decline in the number of workers voluntarily quitting their jobs accelerated sharply lower according to the September report.
  • Small business hiring plans remain well below pre-pandemic levels according to the National Federation of Independent Business.
  • The already-rising percentage of respondents who reported jobs were “hard to get” jumped higher in the latest Conference Board’s Consumer Confidence Survey.

All the above have been useful leading indicators of where the unemployment rate was headed in the following six to 12 months.

ISM New Orders minus Inventories

This indicator has been wobbling around either side of zero. The New Orders Index taken by itself has been painting a negative picture for some time – 22 of the past 24 months have shown new orders contracting for the manufacturing sector. However, inventories have also mostly been contracting over that stretch, leaving the net of the two indexes not telling us very much about the likely course of manufacturing from here.

Reading between the lines

Overall, we think the scorecard is red enough to argue for a cautious, watchful approach to equity investing but, at the same time, not deteriorating at a pace that would unequivocally rule out the possibility of a soft landing for the U.S. economy.

U.S. Recession Scorecard

U.S. recession scorecard
Indicator Status
Yield curve (10-year to 1-year Treasuries) Recessionary
Unemployment claims Neutral/Cautionary
Unemployment rate Recessionary
Conference Board Leading Economic Index Recessionary
Non-financial corporate cash flows Expansionary
ISM New Orders minus Inventories Neutral/Cautionary
Fed funds rate vs. nominal GDP growth Recessionary

Source – RBC Wealth Management


The material herein is for informational purposes only and is not directed at, nor intended for distribution to or use by, any person or entity in any country where such distribution or use would be contrary to law or regulation or which would subject Royal Bank of Canada or its subsidiaries or constituent business units (including RBC Wealth Management) to any licensing or registration requirement within such country.

This is not intended to be either a specific offer by any Royal Bank of Canada entity to sell or provide, or a specific invitation to apply for, any particular financial account, product or service. Royal Bank of Canada does not offer accounts, products or services in jurisdictions where it is not permitted to do so, and therefore the RBC Wealth Management business is not available in all countries or markets.

The information contained herein is general in nature and is not intended, and should not be construed, as professional advice or opinion provided to the user, nor as a recommendation of any particular approach. Nothing in this material constitutes legal, accounting or tax advice and you are advised to seek independent legal, tax and accounting advice prior to acting upon anything contained in this material. Interest rates, market conditions, tax and legal rules and other important factors which will be pertinent to your circumstances are subject to change. This material does not purport to be a complete statement of the approaches or steps that may be appropriate for the user, does not take into account the user’s specific investment objectives or risk tolerance and is not intended to be an invitation to effect a securities transaction or to otherwise participate in any investment service.

To the full extent permitted by law neither RBC Wealth Management nor any of its affiliates, nor any other person, accepts any liability whatsoever for any direct or consequential loss arising from any use of this document or the information contained herein. No matter contained in this material may be reproduced or copied by any means without the prior consent of RBC Wealth Management. RBC Wealth Management is the global brand name to describe the wealth management business of the Royal Bank of Canada and its affiliates and branches, including, RBC Investment Services (Asia) Limited, Royal Bank of Canada, Hong Kong Branch, and the Royal Bank of Canada, Singapore Branch. Additional information available upon request.

Royal Bank of Canada is duly established under the Bank Act (Canada), which provides limited liability for shareholders.

® Registered trademark of Royal Bank of Canada. Used under license. RBC Wealth Management is a registered trademark of Royal Bank of Canada. Used under license. Copyright © Royal Bank of Canada 2025. All rights reserved.


Jim Allworth

Investment Strategist
RBC Dominion Securities

Let’s connect


We want to talk about your financial future.

Related articles

Global equity: Offence still on the field; defence ready for the call

Analysis 7 minute read
- Global equity: Offence still on the field; defence ready for the call

Redder: Updating our recession scorecard

Analysis 4 minute read
- Redder: Updating our recession scorecard

High expectations for the U.S. equity market

Analysis 9 minute read
- High expectations for the U.S. equity market